4 Comments
User's avatar
Fred Porter's avatar

Fun interview. I'm certainly not surprised that, for instance, supermarket owners aren't great at maintaining thousands of panels.

Since I like to check out renewable construction, a few months ago I drove by a repowering project of one of the early utility scale projects in the San Luis Valley, Cogentrix of Alamosa. 30 MW, from 2012, it used dual axis trackers with concentrating lenses on many foot square boxes, with some fancy tiny cells at the back of the box. The lenses were failing. Annual yield went from 65,000 MWh in year one to 35,000 MWh in 2023. Some little company bought it for pennies on the dollar and mounted standard flat panels over the lens boxes and renamed it Alamosa Solar. The yield in 2025 was 76,000 MWh so 20% greater than original, and I think were were still tuning it up.

So it's ready for 30 more years now. This will be the case with almost all utility scale projects. Did this project get any news coverage in CO. Basically, no. Maybe some tiny mention on a biz site.

It bums me out to listen to "debates" about solar projects with much yammering about "decommissioning."

And "recycling." Solar panels are about a 1/4" thick. Each year they avoid the burning of coal about 6" thick for the area of each panel. Each year, so after even after 20 years, that would be a stack of coal under the panel ten feet tall. And then OMG, that, mostly glass, panel probably goes to a landfill. (Aluminum frame will be yanked off.) Any of these "concerned" folks ever live near a rail line near a mine or powerplant. Hundreds of rail cars, day in, day out. Check out the waste volume comparisons in

https://www.nlr.gov/news/detail/program/2023/photovoltaic-toxicity-and-waste-concerns-are-overblown-slowing-decarbonization

Oh yeah, if folks want to reduce or compare landfill waste from something similar... how 'bout asphalt shingles? 25 year life. 80% of the houses in the country. Not quite a 1/4" thick, but over every exposure. My roof was just redone. Big dumpster to the landfill. CO tried to mandate shingle recycling and just ended up with some big festering piles.

Mohd Kamil Vakil, PhD's avatar

The land and the grid connection are the real asset, agreed. Question for Lisa: does adding batteries to an old solar-only interconnection count as a material change that sends it back into the queue? That decides whether it's months or years.

Jerry Wagner's avatar

Regarding public opposition to battery installations, it's important for DER solar developers to know that EOS Energy, located near Pittsbugh PA is already producing cost-effective 100% non-flammable modular aqueous zinc BESS for microgrids and VPPs. EOS BESS are guaranteed for twice as long as lithium BESS, don't need expensive fire supression or cooling systems, and can efficiently discharge for 12 hours or more. They are ideal for behind-the-meter solar canopy parking lot VPPs, equipped with on-site BESS and Vehicle-2-Grid chargers.

Some vintage commercial solar systems, installed over 15 years ago without batteries, can best be replaced, if there's already a parking lot on-site, with a new solar canopy VPP, because V2G chargers enable a smaller capacity BESS with fewer solar panels to match the capacity of the approved interconnection. This strategy helps accelerate EV adoption as well as commercial and multi-family residential building electrification. Solar canopy structures last for 75+years with minimal maintenance, shade hot asphalt parking lots, and shave peak transmission demand for commercial and multi-family HVAC and refrigeration loads.

Rob's avatar

Couldn't be more on point! Repowering and unlocking existing capacity is the ultimate efficiency. It's like the old "nega-watts" concept but so much better! Intensification of electrons at the grid edge is a challenge that quickly becomes the opportunity. While hyperscale data and power are being cancelled, we've got distributed solutions to solve for both sides. Enabling sustainable growth in an electrified and digitized world, will require us to be way more thoughtful about matching up supply and demand (generation with offtaker) on a temporal (virtual) level not just physical. This points to smaller, more localized, more distributed systems and a more intelligent orchestration of the underutilized capacity across every node (interconnection).